MN Injury Case Watch
Hurt in an Out-of-State Crash? Why Minnesota Law Shielded a $500,000 Settlement From a No-Fault Insurer's Reimbursement Claim
Minnesotans who are hurt in a crash outside the state often assume the other state's law controls everything that follows, including whether their own no-fault insurer can later come after their settlement. A recent Minnesota Court of Appeals decision shows why that assumption can be wrong, and why Minnesota's no-fault act can protect an injured person's settlement even when the crash happened hundreds of miles away.
The Facts
What happened
Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina issued an automobile insurance policy to James Janssen, a Minnesota resident, with the policy issued in Minnesota. On March 9, 2022, Janssen suffered serious injuries in a multi-vehicle crash in Boise, Idaho. His policy covered medical expenses and lost wages, and Selective paid him the policy's coverage limit of $20,000 in no-fault benefits.
Janssen hired attorney James Carey of SiebenCarey, P.A. to pursue a negligence claim in Idaho against the other drivers involved in the crash. In March 2023, Selective notified Carey that it was asserting “lien protection” and seeking “reimbursement under [its] subrogation rights” out of whatever Janssen recovered. On June 21, 2023, Janssen settled with the Idaho drivers' insurers for a total of $500,000, releasing the Idaho drivers from further claims.
Selective did not receive any of that settlement. In March 2025, it sued Janssen in Hennepin County District Court for double recovery, breach of contract, and unjust enrichment, and sued Carey for breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, and unjust enrichment, alleging that Carey had improperly distributed the settlement proceeds without first repaying Selective the $20,000 it had paid in no-fault benefits.
Janssen and Carey moved for summary judgment on all of Selective's claims. The district court granted the motion, concluding that there was no need to decide whether Minnesota or Idaho law applied because the lawsuit was between a Minnesota insurer and its own Minnesota insured, and that, applying Minnesota law, Selective had not shown that Janssen received a double recovery. Selective appealed.
The Decision
What the court held
The Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed the grant of summary judgment, in an opinion authored by Judge Wheelock, who presided (Ross, Judge; Harris, Judge). See Selective Insurance Co. of South Carolina v. Janssen, No. A26-0367 (Minn. Ct. App. Oct. 19, 2026). This opinion is nonprecedential. It is not binding authority, although it may be cited for persuasive value as permitted by Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 136.01, subd. 1(c).
Because the material facts were undisputed, the Court of Appeals reviewed the district court's legal conclusions de novo.
Selective did not carry its burden to show that Idaho law should apply
On appeal, Selective argued that the district court should have applied Idaho's subrogation statute instead of Minnesota's. But an appellant has the burden of affirmatively showing error, and Selective's entire argument rested on the assertion that one Minnesota Supreme Court case, Nodak Mutual Insurance Co. v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co., controlled simply because the facts were similar. The Court of Appeals held that was not enough. Minnesota's choice-of-law framework requires a court to work through five specific “choice-influencing factors” from Jepson v. General Casualty Co. of Wisconsin: predictability of result, maintenance of interstate order, simplification of the judicial task, advancement of the forum's governmental interests, and application of the better rule of law. Because Selective never analyzed those factors or explained how they applied to its own case, the court held that Selective failed to meet its burden of showing that the district court erred.
Even on the merits, the factors favored Minnesota law
The court went on to explain that, even if it reached the choice-of-law question, the factors would favor Minnesota law on this record. The first factor (predictability) weighed slightly toward Minnesota because the dispute was between a Minnesota insurer and its own Minnesota insured under a policy issued under Minnesota law. The second factor (interstate order) was neutral because Selective identified no particular interest Idaho had in the dispute. The third factor (simplifying the judicial task) favored Minnesota, since a Minnesota court applying Minnesota law is simpler than applying another state's law. The fourth factor (the forum's interest) weighed heavily toward Minnesota: the no-fault act exists in part to relieve “the severe economic distress of uncompensated victims of automobile accidents” and to correct imbalances in the tort system, and applying Minnesota law here meant Janssen kept the compensation he had received. Because the first four factors were dispositive, the court did not need to reach the fifth factor, the “better rule of law.”
Minnesota's no-fault act limits subrogation to true double recovery
Separately, and central to the result, the court applied Minn. Stat. § 65B.53, subdivision 2, the no-fault act provision governing an insurer's right to reimbursement when its insured is hurt by someone else's negligence in another state. That statute gives an insurer a subrogation right against its own insured only “to the extent that recovery on the claim absent subrogation would produce a duplication of benefits or reimbursement of the same loss.” In other words, Selective could only collect its $20,000 back if Janssen's combined recovery (the no-fault payment plus the $500,000 settlement) amounted to a double recovery for the same injuries. Idaho law, by contrast, would have given Selective a broader subrogation right that did not depend on double recovery.
Selective did not point to evidence in the record showing that Janssen had, in fact, been fully compensated for his injuries by the $500,000 settlement. Without that showing, the court held that Selective's subrogation right never arose under Minnesota law, and the district court properly granted summary judgment for Janssen.
The claims against Janssen's attorney depended entirely on the subrogation right
Selective also argued that Carey breached a fiduciary duty to Selective and that both Carey and Janssen were unjustly enriched by distributing the settlement without first repaying Selective. The Court of Appeals did not reach the merits of those theories independently. Instead, it explained that both claims depended on Selective having a valid subrogation right in the first place. Because Selective's subrogation right never arose, those claims against Carey failed along with the claims against Janssen.
Open Questions
What the court did not decide
The Court of Appeals did not decide, as an independent matter, whether an attorney who distributes settlement proceeds without honoring a lien notice could ever breach a fiduciary duty to the insurer that sent the notice; it decided only that no such duty could exist here because no valid subrogation right existed to protect. The court also did not reach the fifth choice-of-law factor (the better rule of law), since the other factors were dispositive. And because Selective's appeal failed on the threshold burden-of-proof problem, the court's discussion of how the choice-of-law factors would come out on the merits was offered as an alternative explanation, not the sole basis for the decision.
Practical Takeaways
What this means for Minnesota injury claims
- A Minnesota no-fault insurer's reimbursement right from an out-of-state settlement is not automatic. Under Minn. Stat. § 65B.53, subd. 2, the insurer must show that the injured person's total recovery amounted to a double recovery for the same loss. Absent that showing, no subrogation right arises.
- Where you were hurt does not automatically determine which state's subrogation law applies. When the dispute is between a Minnesota insurer and its own Minnesota insured, Minnesota courts may apply Minnesota law even though the underlying crash happened elsewhere.
- Appellants carry the burden on appeal. Simply citing a case with similar facts is not enough; a party challenging a choice-of-law ruling must walk through each of the five Jepson factors and explain how they apply.
- Distributing settlement proceeds is not automatically a breach of duty to an insurer that claims a lien. When the insurer's underlying subrogation right never arose, claims against the handling attorney for distributing funds without reimbursing the insurer can fail along with the claim against the client.
- Keep records of your total recovery. Because a double-recovery showing is fact-specific, documentation of medical expenses, lost wages, and settlement allocation can matter if an insurer later asserts a reimbursement claim.
Related reading from Andrade Law:
- our overview of no-fault insurance and PIP dispute claims, which explains how Minnesota's no-fault benefits work and when an injured person can step outside the no-fault system
- how auto accident litigation and collision claims are handled after a Minnesota crash, from the claims process through a negligence lawsuit against the at-fault driver
- how insurance claim disputes and bad faith litigation are approached when an insurer denies, undervalues, or contests a claim
- our case note on Honcik v. American Family, where a published decision held that a driver hurt by a government vehicle shielded by official immunity could claim uninsured-motorist benefits
- our case note on Kissner v. Farm Bureau, where a self-employed Minnesotan's $250,000 underinsured-motorist wage-loss award was erased for want of records to prove it
- our case note on Villanueva v. GEICO, where a direct lawsuit against the other driver's insurer over a total-loss valuation stayed dismissed on appeal
Case Information
Case information
- Case
- Selective Insurance Company of South Carolina v. James Janssen, et al.
- Docket
- A26-0367
- Court
- Minnesota Court of Appeals
- District court of origin
- Hennepin County District Court (File No. 27-CV-25-3870)
- Filed
- October 19, 2026
- Disposition
- Affirmed (summary judgment for the insured and his attorney)
- Precedential status
- Nonprecedential (may be cited for persuasive value as permitted by Minn. R. Civ. App. P. 136.01, subd. 1(c))
- Authoring judge
- Judge Wheelock, Presiding (Ross, Judge; Harris, Judge)
- Official opinion (mncourts.gov)
- OPa260367-101926.pdf
- Mirror (mn.gov Law Library)
- OPa260367-101926.pdf
Your Attorney
Gabe Andrade
Minnesota Personal Injury Attorney
Gabriel E. Andrade leads Andrade Law with a focus on accountability, careful case-building, and client-first communication. His approach is grounded in the reality that injuries disrupt everything—health, income, family life, and peace of mind—and the legal process should help, not add confusion.
Gabe represents injured Minnesotans in car, truck, and motorcycle crash claims, including the insurance disputes that follow them.
If you’re navigating a serious injury, Gabe and the team can help you understand your options and what a fair path forward could look like.
Professional Associations
Talk with us — free consultation
This post discusses Selective Insurance Co. of South Carolina v. Janssen, No. A26-0367 (Minn. Ct. App. Oct. 19, 2026) (nonprecedential). It is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.